Gov/en/Portal:Rules/Fair-Criteria
💡 In simple words: In simple words: this page lists the rules that decide whether something on WikiDeal is fair, so deals and prices stay honest for everyone.
⚠️ Not yet approved. This page describes a proposal that is still under community review. It is documented here so it can be discussed, improved and endorsed.
WikiDeal Socio-Economic Innovations
This page synthesizes the 25 socio-economic innovations embedded in the WikiDeal model. Each innovation has a named origin — a foundation, movement, or individual thinker — and a brief description. Many innovations build on existing traditions (Wikimedia governance, cooperative movement, token economics) while combining them in novel ways specific to WikiDeal.
Origin legend: 🔵 Wikimedia Foundation 🟢 Théo Bondolfi 🟠 Crypto / Token Economics 🟣 Cooperative Movement 🔴 Free Software Foundation 🌐 Tim Berners-Lee / W3C
| # | Innovation | Origin | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bonding Curve | 🟠 Crypto / Token Economics | Fixed mathematical algorithm governing WIL acquisition prices. The multiplier (discount) decreases as more capital is raised — early funders get the best price, guaranteeing fairness and predictability. The formula is immutable.
T:80%M:20%L:0% |
| 2 | Boost (Funding Stabilizer) | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Auto-regulation mechanism that adjusts the maximum Cash Rewards (no guarantee*) % based on the ratio of platform funding to incompressible costs. Prevents over-rewarding when funds are tight; redirects surplus to community pool when healthy.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 3 | Exit to Community | 🟣 Cooperative (Nathan Schneider) | Progressive transfer of platform governance, ownership, and value from founders/funders to the user community. WikiDeal is designed as an E2C programme from inception — built to be handed over, not held.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 4 | User Groups | 🔵 Wikimedia Foundation | Autonomous local or thematic communities with their own governance, Commission rates, and arbitration. Inspired by Wikimedia User Groups — small, self-organizing, accountable units within a global network.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 5 | Co-opetition | 🔵🟣 Wikimedia + Cooperative | User Groups simultaneously compete (for users, quality, Commissions) and cooperate (sharing protocols, Infrastructure, Rings of Trust). Transparent co-opetition stimulates improvement without destructive rivalry.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 6 | Rings of Trust | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Formal inter-User Group agreements that enable Miles Credits interoperability. A Ring requires ≥2 User Groups and defines the usage coefficients (1–10) for complementary currency exchange within the Ring.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 7 | Dual Rewards (Cash Rewards / Miles Credits) | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Two distinct Credit types: Cash Rewards (no guarantee*, convertible to CHF) and Miles Credits (complementary, usable within Rings of Trust). Gift is an indirect allocation (the difference between bonding curve total and Cash+Miles) — see Rewards Explained. Each type has different tax treatment and social function.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 8 | Deprivatization | 🟢🔵 Théo + Wikimedia | Markets reclaimed by users as commons — analogous to what Wikipedia did for encyclopedic knowledge. WikiDeal targets extractive platforms (babysitting, transport, housing) and converts them to user-governed commons.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 9 | Double Commission | 🔵 Wikimedia Foundation | Every Transaction carries two Commissions: a small WikiDeal platform fee (very small) and a User Group fee (small). Both are at-cost and transparent. Replaces opaque, extractive single-platform fees.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 10 | Collaborative Contract Editing | 🔵 Wikimedia Foundation | Contracts are wiki-edited, versioned, and community-validated — like Wikipedia articles. Any qualified community member can propose improvements; endorsed versions become the standard.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 11 | Peer Endorsement | 🔵 Wikimedia Foundation | Volunteer lawyers endorse contracts, taking editorial responsibility for their legal soundness. Inspired by Wikipedia's peer review and featured article process. Endorsers are named and accountable.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 12 | 5% Annual Value Increase | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Credits gain 5% in CHF value each year. A funder's CHF 1 WIL becomes CHF 1.05 after year 1, CHF 1.63 after year 10. Provides a stable, predictable return anchored in CHF — a safe haven asset.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 13 | CHF 1/Month Subscription | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Entry cost for platform usage: WikiDeal Membership, not a one-time Credits. Solidarity-priced, affordable for all. 1 WIL = 1 month of usage = CHF 1 nominal. The micro-subscription model replaces extractive per-Transaction fees.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 14 | Open Calls | 🔵 Wikimedia Foundation | Seasonal open invitations for community proposals to improve or partially substitute elements of the WikiDeal model. Evaluated March 21, June 21, September 21, December 21. Prize pool: CHF 10,000 + 1M WIL.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 15 | Participatory Observatory | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Internal observatory monitoring community migrations, platform obsolescence risks, fundraising progress, and competitive landscape. Produces reports that feed into Open Calls and governance decisions.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 16 | Arbitration Chambers | 🔵 Théo Bondolfi (inspired by ArbCom Wikimedia) | Three-level arbitration: local chambers → intermediate instance (domain/portal) → ultimate authority with Condorcet voting (Condorcet method). Public citizen debates, mixed expert/public panels.
T:20%M:10%L:70% |
| 17 | AI Disclaimer | 🔵🟢 Wikimedia + Théo | Mandatory AI transparency on every AI-assisted page — similar to Wikipedia's citation requirements. Every AI-generated element must be disclosed, sourced, and marked for human validation.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 18 | Revenue Spreading | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Dialoguers (street fundraisers) choose their payout model: 100% in year 1 OR 20% distributed over 10 years. The 10-year model enables long-term income stability for precarious workers.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 19 | Time & Resource Bank | 🟣 Cooperative / SEL | Exchange housing, transport, food, and services via Miles Credits — inspired by time banks (SEL, LETS) and cooperative resource-sharing movements. Miles Credits becomes a community currency for mutual aid.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 20 | Use Case Maturity Score | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Composite score per marketplace portal based on 7 indicators: users, satisfaction, improvement proposals, urgency, deployment, tool interconnection, usage decline risk. Higher maturity = fewer Open Calls needed.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 21 | Paid Feedback | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Users earn Credits for providing feedback (~1 CHF/min). Deductions apply if feedback is not provided after a Transaction. Incentivizes quality evaluation loops and continuous improvement.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 22 | Judgment Balance Indicator | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Auto-weighting algorithm that adjusts extreme ratings (1-star, 5-star) based on historical patterns. Stimulates honest, calibrated feedback — prevents gaming by chronic over-raters or punishers.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 23 | Wikimedia Marker (WM-XX) | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi | Blue graphical nomenclature marking elements directly inspired by Wikimedia Foundation practices. Provides visual attribution and traceability — e.g., WM-01 (User Groups), WM-02 (Open Call), WM-03 (ArbCom).
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 24 | Systematic Libre Licensing | 🔴 Free Software Foundation | AGPL v3 for all software, CC BY-SA 4.0 for all content — everywhere, by default. No exceptions. Guarantees that WikiDeal's commons cannot be privatized by derivative works or forked proprietary versions.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 25 | Structured Data (Linked Data) | 🌐 Tim Berners-Lee / W3C | RDF, JSON-LD, and Wikidata integration throughout WikiDeal's data layer. Enables semantic interoperability, federated search, and machine-readable transparency — aligned with the original vision of the Semantic Web.
T:33%M:33%L:33% |
| 26 | Fair Transition (CDIEM) | 🟢 Théo Bondolfi
(based on Zenodo CDIEM) |
A smooth transition mechanism to fully peer-to-peer review for community innovations (Open Calls). It ensures meritocratic reward attribution based on deferred evaluation—measuring both the duration and breadth of an idea's deployment. Rewards are proportional to long-term added value, not just initial acceptance.
T:40%M:20%G:40% |
About This Synthesis
These 26 innovations did not emerge from a single moment of invention. They crystallized over years of practice — running digital commons projects, observing platform cooperative failures, studying Wikimedia governance, and experimenting with complementary currencies. WikiDeal's distinctiveness lies not in any single innovation, but in their combination and mutual reinforcement.
This page is a living document. As WikiDeal evolves through Open Calls and community contributions, innovations may be refined, replaced, or supplemented. Attribution will always be maintained.
Note: "Imagination" in the WikiDeal lexicon means "thoughtful, grounded speculation rooted in lived experience and evidence" — not fantasy. These innovations are proposals for real implementation, not theoretical exercises.
See also: Wiki Core Index Open Calls & Maturity Why Fund WikiDeal Wikimedia References Glossary