Jump to content
Gov  ·  Market  ·  Community  ·  Policies  ·  Funding  ·  Open Call  ·  Get started

Gov/en/Portal:R&D/Open-Call:FAQ: Difference between revisions

Terminology: miles / Miles Credits -> WIL token (WikiDeal Inner Life), Theo 2026-07-16
Maturity criterion answer: point to User Group Maturity page as second-tranche indicator (Theo 2026-07-25)
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 27: Line 27:
'''Is there an age requirement? Can minors participate?'''
'''Is there an age requirement? Can minors participate?'''


Proposed answer, under discussion: ideas would be welcome from anyone, including young people. However, paying money to a minor raises legal questions that differ by country, so any payment to a minor would require the consent of a legal guardian and would be examined case by case. Options without cash, such as WIL tokens only or participation without remuneration, could make participation simpler for minors. This point is not yet decided.
Proposed answer, under discussion: ideas would be welcome from anyone, including young people. However, paying money to a minor raises legal questions that differ by country, so any payment to a minor would require the consent of a legal guardian and would be examined case by case. Options without cash, such as Karma tokens only or participation without remuneration, could make participation simpler for minors. This point is not yet decided.


'''Can I participate anonymously or under a pseudonym?'''
'''Can I participate anonymously or under a pseudonym?'''


Proposed answer: contributing ideas under a wiki pseudonym would be possible, as on most wikis. Receiving a cash payment, however, would require a verified identity and a bank account (IBAN), for legal and accounting reasons. A pseudonymous contributor could therefore choose WIL tokens only, or participate without remuneration, and keep the pseudonym. Details are under discussion.
Proposed answer: contributing ideas under a wiki pseudonym would be possible, as on most wikis. Receiving a cash payment, however, would require a verified identity and a bank account (IBAN), for legal and accounting reasons. A pseudonymous contributor could therefore choose Karma tokens only, or participate without remuneration, and keep the pseudonym. Details are under discussion.


'''Can I participate without receiving any money?'''
'''Can I participate without receiving any money?'''


Proposed answer: yes. Three options are proposed: full participation with cash and Rewards (no guarantee), participation with WIL tokens only and no cash, and participation without any remuneration at all. Contributors would state their preference; many people contribute to free knowledge projects without payment, and that choice would be fully respected here.
Proposed answer: yes. Three options are proposed: full participation with cash and Rewards (no guarantee), participation with Karma tokens only and no cash, and participation without any remuneration at all. Contributors would state their preference; many people contribute to free knowledge projects without payment, and that choice would be fully respected here.


'''Can I both submit my own ideas and give my opinion on the contributions of others?'''
'''Can I both submit my own ideas and give my opinion on the contributions of others?'''
Line 128: Line 128:
'''What is the difference between direct cash and Rewards (no guarantee)?'''
'''What is the difference between direct cash and Rewards (no guarantee)?'''


Proposed answer: direct cash is money actually paid to your bank account once attributed. Rewards (no guarantee) are a conditional mechanism linked to future subscription revenue of the platform: they may translate into value later if the project develops, and they may not. The two are always kept distinct in the call tables, and no promise is attached to Rewards. WIL tokens are a third form, usable for services within the ecosystem.
Proposed answer: direct cash is money actually paid to your bank account once attributed. Rewards (no guarantee) are a conditional mechanism linked to future subscription revenue of the platform: they may translate into value later if the project develops, and they may not. The two are always kept distinct in the call tables, and no promise is attached to Rewards. Karma tokens are a third form, usable for services within the ecosystem.


'''Why can part of the sum be withheld for up to one year? What is the maturity criterion?'''
'''Why can part of the sum be withheld for up to one year? What is the maturity criterion?'''


Proposed answer: the committee wants to distinguish a solid base from a flash in the pan. A contribution can deserve money directly, or partly: in that case a part is paid at attribution and the rest is kept by the committee and attributed according to how long the idea stays in use and remains useful over time. For example, half of a sum could be paid immediately and the other half one year later, if the idea has lasted, as an increase of the donation. The exact split would be stated at attribution.
Proposed answer: the committee wants to distinguish a solid base from a flash in the pan. A contribution can deserve money directly, or partly: in that case a part is paid at attribution and the rest is kept by the committee and attributed according to how long the idea stays in use and remains useful over time. For example, half of a sum could be paid immediately and the other half one year later, if the idea has lasted, as an increase of the donation. The exact split would be stated at attribution. To assess whether the idea has lasted, the [[Gov/en/Portal:R&D/User-Group-Maturity|Maturity Score of the concerned User Group]] can be used as an indicator: for example, whether real deployment has taken place one year later. The Maturity Score measures the health of User Groups and their marketplaces (not of the open calls themselves); its use here is limited to informing the release of a second tranche.


'''Do I need a bank account (IBAN)? What if I do not have one?'''
'''Do I need a bank account (IBAN)? What if I do not have one?'''


Proposed answer: yes, an IBAN is the proposed default for cash payments. If you do not have one, or do not wish to share one, the proposed alternatives are WIL tokens only, or participation without remuneration. Other payment channels are not planned for the first period, mainly to keep accounting simple and verifiable; this could be revisited later.
Proposed answer: yes, an IBAN is the proposed default for cash payments. If you do not have one, or do not wish to share one, the proposed alternatives are Karma tokens only, or participation without remuneration. Other payment channels are not planned for the first period, mainly to keep accounting simple and verifiable; this could be revisited later.


'''What are WIL tokens and how can I use them?'''
'''What are Karma tokens and how can I use them?'''


Proposed answer: WIL tokens are the internal credits of the WikiDeal ecosystem, usable for services within it. A contributor can choose to receive part or all of a reward in WIL tokens instead of cash. They are not money, they are not convertible on demand, and their scope of use would grow with the ecosystem itself.
Proposed answer: Karma tokens are the internal credits of the WikiDeal ecosystem, usable for services within it. A contributor can choose to receive part or all of a reward in Karma tokens instead of cash. They are not money, they are not convertible on demand, and their scope of use would grow with the ecosystem itself.


<span id="rights"></span>
<span id="rights"></span>
Line 184: Line 184:


----
----
'''See also:''' [[Gov/en/Portal:R&D/Open-Call:Main|Open Call page]] · [[Gov/en/Portal:R&D/Open-Calls-Maturity|Open Calls & Maturity Score System]]
'''See also:''' [[Gov/en/Portal:R&D/Open-Call:Main|Open Call page]] · [[Gov/en/Portal:R&D/User-Group-Maturity|User Group Maturity Assessment]]


[[Category:Migration June 2026]]
[[Category:Migration June 2026]]