Gov/en/Portal:Rules/Fair-Criteria - Revision history

AI-Admin-Assistant: Add missing intros per Theo's 20s rule

2026-08-09T00:58:30Z

Add missing intros per Theo's 20s rule

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:58, 9 August 2026
Line 1:		Line 1:
			{{ExpertIntro\|This page synthesizes 25 socio-economic innovations embedded in WikiDeal's governance model. The emerging trend suggests integrating bonding curves, need-driven funding, and exit-to-community mechanisms to create user-governed platforms that balance market competition with cooperative stewardship, progressively transferring value from founders to communities while maintaining transparent, at-cost commission structures.}}

	{{KidsIntro\|this page lists the rules that decide whether something on WikiDeal is fair, so deals and prices stay honest for everyone.}}		{{KidsIntro\|this page lists the rules that decide whether something on WikiDeal is fair, so deals and prices stay honest for everyone.}}

AI-Admin-Assistant: Terminology: remove Miles Market / Dual Rewards; Karma tokens only (Theo 2026-08-07)

2026-08-07T13:55:46Z

Terminology: remove Miles Market / Dual Rewards; Karma tokens only (Theo 2026-08-07)

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:55, 7 August 2026
Line 63:		Line 63:
	\|-		\|-
	\| 7		\| 7
	\| '''~~Dual~~ Rewards''' ~~(Rewards / Karma tokens)~~		\| '''Rewards and Karma tokens'''
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Two distinct ~~Reward forms~~: ~~cash-out~~ Rewards (no guarantee*, convertible to CHF) and Karma tokens (complementary, usable within Rings of Trust). Gift is an indirect allocation (the difference between bonding curve total and Cash+Karma tokens), see [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards Explained]]. Each ~~form~~ has different tax treatment and social function.		\| Two distinct mechanisms: Rewards (no guarantee*, convertible to CHF) and Karma tokens (complementary, usable within Rings of Trust). Gift is an indirect allocation (the difference between bonding curve total and Cash+Karma tokens), see [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards Explained]]. Each has a different tax treatment and social function.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%

AI-Admin-Assistant: Rename Open Call to Open Calls; remove reputation credits (Theo 2026-08-03)

2026-08-03T19:51:14Z

Rename Open Call to Open Calls; remove reputation credits (Theo 2026-08-03)

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:51, 3 August 2026
Line 119:		Line 119:
	\|-		\|-
	\| 14		\| 14
	\| '''[[Gov/en/Portal:R&D/Open-~~Call~~:Main\|Open Call]]s'''		\| '''[[Gov/en/Portal:R&D/Open-Calls:Main\|Open Call]]s'''
	\| 🔵 Wikimedia Foundation		\| 🔵 Wikimedia Foundation
	\| Seasonal open invitations for community proposals to improve or partially substitute elements of the WikiDeal model. Evaluated March 21, June 21, September 21, December 21. Prize pool: CHF 10,000 + 1M WIL.		\| Seasonal open invitations for community proposals to improve or partially substitute elements of the WikiDeal model. Evaluated March 21, June 21, September 21, December 21. Prize pool: CHF 10,000 + 1M WIL.

AI-Admin-Assistant: Rewards vocabulary: umbrella term Credits renamed to Rewards (Theo 2026-08-03)

2026-08-03T06:58:52Z

Rewards vocabulary: umbrella term Credits renamed to Rewards (Theo 2026-08-03)

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:58, 3 August 2026
Line 65:		Line 65:
	\| '''Dual Rewards''' (Rewards / Karma tokens)		\| '''Dual Rewards''' (Rewards / Karma tokens)
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Two distinct ~~Credit types~~: Rewards (no guarantee*, convertible to CHF) and Karma tokens (complementary, usable within Rings of Trust). Gift is an indirect allocation (the difference between bonding curve total and Cash+Karma tokens), see [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards Explained]]. Each ~~type~~ has different tax treatment and social function.		\| Two distinct Reward forms: cash-out Rewards (no guarantee*, convertible to CHF) and Karma tokens (complementary, usable within Rings of Trust). Gift is an indirect allocation (the difference between bonding curve total and Cash+Karma tokens), see [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards Explained]]. Each form has different tax treatment and social function.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%
Line 113:		Line 113:
	\| '''CHF 1/Month Subscription'''		\| '''CHF 1/Month Subscription'''
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Entry cost for platform usage: WikiDeal Membership, not a one-time ~~Credits~~. Solidarity-priced, affordable for all. 1 WIL = 1 month of usage = CHF 1 nominal. The micro-[[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Subscriptions\|subscription model]] replaces extractive per-Transaction fees.		\| Entry cost for platform usage: WikiDeal Membership, not a one-time Rewards purchase. Solidarity-priced, affordable for all. 1 WIL = 1 month of usage = CHF 1 nominal. The micro-[[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Subscriptions\|subscription model]] replaces extractive per-Transaction fees.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%
Line 177:		Line 177:
	\| '''Paid Feedback'''		\| '''Paid Feedback'''
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Users earn ~~Credits~~ for providing feedback (~1 CHF/min). Deductions apply if feedback is not provided after a Transaction. Incentivizes quality evaluation loops and continuous improvement.		\| Users earn Rewards for providing feedback (~1 CHF/min). Deductions apply if feedback is not provided after a Transaction. Incentivizes quality evaluation loops and continuous improvement.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%

AI-Admin-Assistant: Terminology: WIL token -> Karma token; WIL = WikiDeal License only (Theo 2026-07-16)

2026-07-16T21:55:28Z

Terminology: WIL token -> Karma token; WIL = WikiDeal License only (Theo 2026-07-16)

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:55, 16 July 2026
Line 57:		Line 57:
	\| '''Rings of Trust'''		\| '''Rings of Trust'''
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Formal inter-User Group agreements that enable [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/~~WIL~~-Tokens\|~~WIL~~ tokens]] interoperability. A Ring requires ≥2 User Groups and defines the usage coefficients (1 to 10) for complementary currency exchange within the Ring.		\| Formal inter-User Group agreements that enable [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Karma-Tokens\|Karma tokens]] interoperability. A Ring requires ≥2 User Groups and defines the usage coefficients (1 to 10) for complementary currency exchange within the Ring.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%
Line 63:		Line 63:
	\|-		\|-
	\| 7		\| 7
	\| '''Dual Rewards''' (Rewards / ~~WIL~~ tokens)		\| '''Dual Rewards''' (Rewards / Karma tokens)
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Two distinct Credit types: Rewards (no guarantee*, convertible to CHF) and ~~WIL~~ tokens (complementary, usable within Rings of Trust). Gift is an indirect allocation (the difference between bonding curve total and Cash+~~WIL~~ tokens), see [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards Explained]]. Each type has different tax treatment and social function.		\| Two distinct Credit types: Rewards (no guarantee*, convertible to CHF) and Karma tokens (complementary, usable within Rings of Trust). Gift is an indirect allocation (the difference between bonding curve total and Cash+Karma tokens), see [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards Explained]]. Each type has different tax treatment and social function.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%
Line 161:		Line 161:
	\| '''Time & Resource Bank'''		\| '''Time & Resource Bank'''
	\| 🟣 Cooperative / SEL		\| 🟣 Cooperative / SEL
	\| Exchange housing, transport, food, and services via ~~WIL~~ tokens, inspired by time banks (SEL, LETS) and cooperative resource-sharing movements. ~~WIL~~ tokens become a community currency for mutual aid.		\| Exchange housing, transport, food, and services via Karma tokens, inspired by time banks (SEL, LETS) and cooperative resource-sharing movements. Karma tokens become a community currency for mutual aid.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%

AI-Admin-Assistant: Terminology: miles / Miles Credits -> WIL token (WikiDeal Inner Life), Theo 2026-07-16

2026-07-16T19:47:54Z

Terminology: miles / Miles Credits -> WIL token (WikiDeal Inner Life), Theo 2026-07-16

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:47, 16 July 2026
Line 57:		Line 57:
	\| '''Rings of Trust'''		\| '''Rings of Trust'''
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Formal inter-User Group agreements that enable [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/~~Miles~~-~~Credits~~\|~~Miles Credits~~]] interoperability. A Ring requires ≥2 User Groups and defines the usage coefficients (1 to 10) for complementary currency exchange within the Ring.		\| Formal inter-User Group agreements that enable [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/WIL-Tokens\|WIL tokens]] interoperability. A Ring requires ≥2 User Groups and defines the usage coefficients (1 to 10) for complementary currency exchange within the Ring.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%
Line 63:		Line 63:
	\|-		\|-
	\| 7		\| 7
	\| '''Dual Rewards''' (Rewards / ~~Miles Credits~~)		\| '''Dual Rewards''' (Rewards / WIL tokens)
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Two distinct Credit types: Rewards (no guarantee*, convertible to CHF) and ~~Miles Credits~~ (complementary, usable within Rings of Trust). Gift is an indirect allocation (the difference between bonding curve total and Cash+~~Miles~~), see [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards Explained]]. Each type has different tax treatment and social function.		\| Two distinct Credit types: Rewards (no guarantee*, convertible to CHF) and WIL tokens (complementary, usable within Rings of Trust). Gift is an indirect allocation (the difference between bonding curve total and Cash+WIL tokens), see [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards Explained]]. Each type has different tax treatment and social function.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%
Line 161:		Line 161:
	\| '''Time & Resource Bank'''		\| '''Time & Resource Bank'''
	\| 🟣 Cooperative / SEL		\| 🟣 Cooperative / SEL
	\| Exchange housing, transport, food, and services via ~~Miles Credits~~, inspired by time banks (SEL, LETS) and cooperative resource-sharing movements. ~~Miles Credits becomes~~ a community currency for mutual aid.		\| Exchange housing, transport, food, and services via WIL tokens, inspired by time banks (SEL, LETS) and cooperative resource-sharing movements. WIL tokens become a community currency for mutual aid.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%

AI-Admin-Assistant: Terminology pass 2: unify historical names (Balanced Boost, Balance Boost, The Boost) under Need-Driven Funding

2026-07-07T03:38:17Z

Terminology pass 2: unify historical names (Balanced Boost, Balance Boost, The Boost) under Need-Driven Funding

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:38, 7 July 2026
Line 23:		Line 23:
	\|-		\|-
	\| 2		\| 2
	\| '''~~Boost''' (~~Need-Driven Funding)		\| '''Need-Driven Funding'''
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Auto-regulation mechanism that adjusts the maximum [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards]] (no guarantee*) % based on the ratio of platform funding to incompressible costs. Prevents over-rewarding when funds are tight; redirects surplus to community pool when healthy.		\| Auto-regulation mechanism that adjusts the maximum [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards]] (no guarantee*) % based on the ratio of platform funding to incompressible costs. Prevents over-rewarding when funds are tight; redirects surplus to community pool when healthy.

AI-Admin-Assistant: Terminology: Need-Driven Funding replaces Funding Stabilizer / Boost mechanism (Theo 2026-07-07)

2026-07-07T03:37:10Z

Terminology: Need-Driven Funding replaces Funding Stabilizer / Boost mechanism (Theo 2026-07-07)

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:37, 7 July 2026
Line 23:		Line 23:
	\|-		\|-
	\| 2		\| 2
	\| '''Boost''' (Funding ~~Stabilizer~~)		\| '''Boost''' (Need-Driven Funding)
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Auto-regulation mechanism that adjusts the maximum [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards]] (no guarantee*) % based on the ratio of platform funding to incompressible costs. Prevents over-rewarding when funds are tight; redirects surplus to community pool when healthy.		\| Auto-regulation mechanism that adjusts the maximum [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Rewards\|Rewards]] (no guarantee*) % based on the ratio of platform funding to incompressible costs. Prevents over-rewarding when funds are tight; redirects surplus to community pool when healthy.

AI-Admin-Assistant: Update voting link after move to dedicated Portal:Voting

2026-07-05T04:13:29Z

Update voting link after move to dedicated Portal:Voting

← Older revision		Revision as of 06:13, 5 July 2026
Line 137:		Line 137:
	\| '''Arbitration Chambers'''		\| '''Arbitration Chambers'''
	\| 🔵 WikiDeal concept (inspired by ArbCom Wikimedia)		\| 🔵 WikiDeal concept (inspired by ArbCom Wikimedia)
	\| Three-level arbitration: local chambers → intermediate instance (domain/portal) → ultimate authority with Condorcet voting ([https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Condorcet_method Condorcet method]). Public citizen debates, mixed expert/public panels. See [[Gov/en/Portal:~~Institutions~~/~~Voting-~~Main\|Voting at WikiDeal]].		\| Three-level arbitration: local chambers → intermediate instance (domain/portal) → ultimate authority with Condorcet voting ([https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Condorcet_method Condorcet method]). Public citizen debates, mixed expert/public panels. See [[Gov/en/Portal:Voting/Main\|Voting at WikiDeal]].

	T:20%M:10%L:70%		T:20%M:10%L:70%

AI-Admin-Assistant: Typography: replace pre-existing en-dash (1-10 range) per zero-dash rule

2026-07-05T03:51:19Z

Typography: replace pre-existing en-dash (1-10 range) per zero-dash rule

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:51, 5 July 2026
Line 57:		Line 57:
	\| '''Rings of Trust'''		\| '''Rings of Trust'''
	\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept		\| 🟢 WikiDeal concept
	\| Formal inter-User Group agreements that enable [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Miles-Credits\|Miles Credits]] interoperability. A Ring requires ≥2 User Groups and defines the usage coefficients (~~1–10~~) for complementary currency exchange within the Ring.		\| Formal inter-User Group agreements that enable [[Gov/en/Portal:Economy/Miles-Credits\|Miles Credits]] interoperability. A Ring requires ≥2 User Groups and defines the usage coefficients (1 to 10) for complementary currency exchange within the Ring.

	T:33%M:33%L:33%		T:33%M:33%L:33%